论我国民事诉讼审前争点整理程序的构建

来源 :山西大学 | 被引量 : 3次 | 上传用户:Rosa1201
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
In civil procedure designs, the reform has a transition from the trial system to the civil procedure system, of which civil pretrial procedure is one of the key issues to bring about such a reform. Because issue identification in pretrial is a subroutine procedure, the research is of great significance. On one hand, issue identification exists in all stages of the procedures in practice, which belongs to the scope in which the judge of the case and analyze the adjudicating cases. It is objective and actual. On the other hand, viewing from the function of pretrial procedure, due to the lack of the issue identification in pretrial procedures in China the exchange and identification of evidence cannot play a key role. Therefore, the construction of issue identification in pretrial procedure is imperative. In practice, the judges can summarize the controversial focus in the cases, which is arbitrary, chaotic, and without a system to follow. Thus, while the issue identification in civil pretrial procedure is constructed, we must realize the objectivity and actuality of it and follow the reasonable notion to restricts and design. "Centralism of judgment" and "synergy" are the governing law of the civil issue identification procedures.The system of civil procedure is reformed according to "concentration", which is the second leap in the way of civil trial system. "Centralism of judgment" requires to fix the trial scopes before the civil trial , identify the issues and entitle it effect, namely, new advocates, facts or evidence which affect the case judges are not allowed to be supposed freely during the trial in order to concentrate on the trial and raise the efficiency of the procedures. As to the links that affect the burden of evidence and the choice of claims of the case trial, the judger has the obligations to make statements for the party. Besides, the traditional suppression-trial-atmosphere is abandoned, Instead, the dialogue-exchange-atmosphere between the judge and the party is advocated. So, the writer insists that "written simple issue identification" and "meeting-type issue identification" be established in our country. The first part is the basic theory of issue identification in pretrial procedure. It mainly analyzes the connotation and extension of issue and differentiate between issue and related concepts. Meanwhile, it elaborates on the meaning of issue identification in pretrial procedure and explains the relation between issue identification in pretrial procedure and related procedures so as to grasp the substance of issue identification in pretrial . "No issues, no judges". Issues are the substance to forming the case dispute. The writer understand the issues in a broad sense, that is, the controversial questions between parties that affect the result of the case trial are issues, including the fact issues, law issues, evidence issues and procedure issues. It differentiates among the issues, the subject of litigation and controversial focus. The issue identification procedures and exchanges of evidence both interdependent and independent on each other. To prove time system is a technical devices to guarantee the formation of the issues, otherwise, the formation of the issues is just empty talk.The second part is an essential analysis of the issues identification in pretrial procedures from the governing law of construction and the practical significance of the construction. Speaking from the macro perspective, the structure of civil procedures in our country is faced with changes, the trend of modern civil procedure is "concentration", that is, the case should be completed in one trial phase and it oppose the attack of repeated court and procedures. The issues identification in pretrial procedures come into being under the guidance of this notion.The third part is the study of issue identification in pretrial procedure in other countries and areas. It analyzes the issues identification in civil pretrial procedures of America, France, Germany, Japan and Taiwan of China. Taking a panoramic view of all the issue identification in pretrial procedures in all countries, there are prepared-oral-debate-type pretrial system, conference-type hearing, civil pretrial issue identification manners instead of or even rejecting the court procedures, judge-led the issue identification mode in pretrial procedures, party- oriented the issue identification mode in pretrial procedures. It compares the issues identification in pretrial procedure between all the countries and Taiwan and analyzes the commonalities and differences.The fourth part analyzes the legal provisions and practical operation of China’s current stage. The issue identification in pretrial procedure system has not been formed, the party’s dominant position is not enough, there is no appropriate system for the judges to follow in summarizing the issues arbitrarily, which influences the realization of the pretrial procedure function.The fifth part sets forth the specific ideas to construct the issue identification in pretrial procedure of China, which must based on the China’s national condition and pay attention to the effective interface to the related system. In addition, the construction of the issue identification in pretrial procedure can not be completed overnight, but a gradual process. During the construction of the issues identification in pretrial procedure, we should grasp the relation between the issue identification in civil pretrial procedure and the court judges in order to choose reasonable modes and manners of the issue identification in pretrial procedure and distribute properly the rights and obligation between the party and the judge. The writer proposes "written simple issue identification" and "meeting-type issue identification".
其他文献
随着全球范围内信息数字化、网络化进程的加快,人类己进入到信息社会。她悄然改变整个人类社会的生产、生活方式,给我们生活的每一个领域都带来了前所未有、难以置信的全方位的
针对在现场条件开展混凝土渗透性检测的要求,结合混凝土表层水吸附性ISAT法和混凝土保护层抗氯离子渗透性Permit试验的评价结果,对两种不同混凝土空气渗透性检测技术的CLAM t
本文通过对荣华二采区10
期刊
商会无论在国内市场,还是在国际贸易领域的功能都很广泛。参与反倾销活动是商会在国际贸易领域最具代表性的功能,同时,也是我国加入WTO后最需要加强的功能,正是由于商会在申请反
宪法是国家的根本大法,规定一个国家的最根本最重要的问题。宪法具有最高法律效力,拥有最高权威,是其他法律制度产生的基础和依据,也是国家中一切主体的行为准则。宪法解释不仅可
抗风设计对建筑幕墙极为重要。本文从风致幕墙结构破坏的特点、幕墙风荷载取值存在的问题、风洞试验在幕墙抗风设计方面的应用等方面讨论,并以工程实例说明了风洞试验可以优