论文部分内容阅读
台湾地区的刑事判例制度在实现法律续造、统一法律见解等方面发挥了重要的作用,但同时也存在违背权力分立和法官独立审判原则、刑事判例变更不妥当等问题。大陆地区的刑事案例指导制度是我国司法实践的新产物,它是我国在推动司法科学化、规范化、公正化的过程中建立的。目前,我们应当充分汲取台湾地区刑事判例制度的成功经验,避免其出现的问题,使刑事案例指导制度不断完善。
The criminal precedent system in Taiwan has played an important role in restoring the law and unifying the legal opinions. However, it also runs counter to the principle of separation of powers and the principle of independent trial of judges, and the improper change of criminal precedent. The criminal case guidance system in mainland China is a new product of judicial practice in our country. It was established in the process of promoting judicial scientification, standardization and fairness in our country. At present, we should fully draw on the successful experience of the criminal case law system in Taiwan, avoid the problems that have arisen, and constantly improve the criminal case guidance system.