读1957年本刊9月号庄松峯同志的“我对红升丹的认识”一文,他提出了对我稿的不同意见,予我帮助很大,可是有些地方的说服力不够强.今再与庄同志商榷,并希不吝指教为幸.一、我对红升丹的疗效分析,也是依据金鉴记载而来.由于金鉴列有去腐类方和生肌类方两个部门,再结合到我的临床经验,因此认为去腐类方是适用于一切溃疡的肉芽不红活、分泌物多的病例;生肌类方则适用于溃疡的肉芽新鲜、分泌物少的病例的. I read Comrade Zhuang Songfeng’s article “I Understand Hong Dandan” in September issue of the 1957 issue of Comrade Zhuang Songfeng. He presented different opinions on my manuscript and gave me great help. However, the persuasion in some places was not strong enough. Comrade Zhuang this time to discuss with Zhuang and hope to be fortunate. I. The analysis of the efficacy of Hong Shengdan is based on Jin Jian’s records. As Jin Jian lists the two departments of detoxification and detoxification, Combined with my clinical experience, it is considered that the rot-like category is suitable for all cases of ulcers, granules are not red, and many secretions; myogenic class is suitable for ulcers of fresh and low secretion of the case of granulation.