论文部分内容阅读
本文首先通过对鉴定意见司法审查现状的解读,分析了对鉴定意见加强司法审查的必要性;其次就司法审判过于依赖鉴定意见的根本原因进行了深入剖析,指出其根源在于事实发现的客观需要、司法鉴定的技术壁垒、崇拜权威的思维定势以及趋利避害的风险权衡。最后,强调通过重塑法官的鉴定审查意识和加强对鉴定意见的审查规制,为实现鉴定依赖的最终消解寻找路径。
Firstly, through the interpretation of the status quo of the judicial review of the appraisal opinion, the article analyzes the necessity of strengthening the judicial review of the appraisal opinion. Secondly, the paper analyzes the root cause of the judicial trial relying too much on the appraisal opinions, points out that the root cause lies in the objective need of the fact finding, The technical barriers of forensic appraisal, the thinking tendency of worshiping the authority and the trade-off between risk and profit. Finally, it emphasizes the search for a path to reshape judges’ accreditation and to strengthen the review and control of accreditation opinions so as to achieve the final resolution of accreditation and dependence.